Across the family dinner table, my sister-in-law shrugged after returning my late mother’s stand mixer with a completely burned-out motor. “It was probably on its last legs anyway,” she said, not even bothering to look at me. “Just get a new one.”
The entire table went silent. This was the cherished mixer my mom gave me right before she died, the one Chloe begged to borrow and then treated like garbage.
Her lack of remorse was breathtaking. She didn’t care that she’d destroyed a piece of my heart.
But she cared about one thing: the annual county fair bake-off, a competition she was pathologically obsessed with winning. She had no idea my mother’s final gift wasn’t just the mixer, but the insurance policy that came with it, and I was about to use my mom’s own prize-winning recipe to beat her at the one game she lived to play.
A Simple Favor: The Heart of the Kitchen
The motor hummed a low, steady B-flat. It was a sound more comforting than almost any other I knew. My son, Leo, was at a sleepover, my husband, Mark, was on a late conference call in his office, and I had the kitchen to myself. A deadline for a new logo design for a particularly indecisive dental firm had left my brain feeling like a wrung-out sponge. Baking was my reset button.
The Empire Red KitchenAid stand mixer sat on the granite countertop, a solid, gleaming anchor in the sea of my day. Flour dusted its base like a soft halo. I scraped the sides of the stainless-steel bowl with a silicone spatula, guiding the fragrant cinnamon-roll dough back toward the hook. The machine kneaded onward, its rhythmic thumping a steady heartbeat in the quiet house.
It was the last gift my mother gave me before she died. “Every kitchen needs a heart, Sarah,” she’d said, her hands, already frail, resting on top of mine. “This is yours.” She’d even bought the extended retail insurance policy for it, a classic Mom move. “You never know,” she’d winked. “It’s a good machine, but life happens.”
I talked to it sometimes. To her, really. “It’s a good batch, Mom,” I murmured, leaning in to catch the sweet, yeasty scent. “Leo will be thrilled when he gets home tomorrow.”
The mixer felt less like an appliance and more like a part of my body, an extension of my memory. It was solid, reliable, and powerful. It was everything my mother had been.
The Hurricane
The chime of the doorbell was so sharp and unexpected it made me jump, sending a puff of flour into the air. I sighed, turning off the mixer. Mark’s call must have ended. But when I pulled open the front door, it wasn’t my husband. It was his sister, Chloe.
Chloe doesn’t just enter a room; she detonates in it. Her oversized purse, stuffed to the point of bursting, swung from her shoulder. Her hair was a messy bun that looked both accidental and deliberate. She was already talking before she was fully inside, a frantic, high-energy monologue about a disastrous trip to the craft store and her son’s diorama project.
“—and then Dylan, you know how he is, decides he needs authentic, ethically sourced moss, not the green sponge I bought. Where do you even find that? Is there a moss farm? My God, Sarah, your house smells amazing.” She breezed past me into the kitchen, her eyes immediately landing on the mixer. “Ooh, cinnamon rolls.”
She dropped her purse on a chair, and a cascade of receipts, a half-eaten granola bar, and a single, rogue crayon spilled onto the floor. She didn’t seem to notice. Her focus was entirely on the bowl of perfect, elastic dough resting in my silent mixer.
The Inevitable Ask
“That thing is such a beast,” Chloe said, running a finger over the red enamel. I resisted the urge to wipe the spot with a cloth. “I swear, you could mix concrete in it and it would just ask for more.”
I offered a tight smile. “It gets the job done.”
“You’re telling me.” She leaned against the counter, the frantic energy coalescing into a focused beam of desperation. I knew this look. It was the preamble to a favor. “You are an absolute lifesaver for even listening to me right now, but I am in a world of hurt.”
She launched into the story. Her own cheap stand mixer, a brand I’d never heard of, had apparently “given up the ghost” in the middle of a massive batch of cupcakes for the PTA fundraiser. She had promised two hundred cupcakes, frosted and decorated, by tomorrow morning.
“I’m the head of the committee, I can’t just not show up with them. It would be a catastrophe,” she lamented, her eyes wide and pleading. “I don’t know what to do. I was thinking of trying to mix it all by hand, but my wrist would probably snap in half.” She paused, her gaze flicking from my face to the mixer and back again. “I don’t suppose… I know it’s a lot to ask, Sarah. I know how much you love this thing. But could I possibly borrow it? Just for tonight. I’ll have it back to you by noon tomorrow, sparkling clean. I swear.”
Every cell in my body screamed No. It was a primal, protective instinct. This wasn’t a casserole dish or a cup of sugar. This was my mother’s last gift. This was the heart of my kitchen.
The Sinking Feeling
I hesitated for a fraction too long, and Chloe seized the opening. “You would be saving my life. My social life, anyway. Linda Peterson would have a field day if I messed this up.”
I thought of Mark. I could already hear his voice, that gentle, placating tone he used whenever his sister was involved. Come on, hon. It’s just for one night. It’s important to her. Let’s just keep the peace. The endless, exhausting tightrope walk of being a daughter-in-law. Saying no would mean a week of tense phone calls, of Mark trying to mediate a conflict that shouldn’t even exist. It would make me the difficult one. The selfish one.
My shoulders slumped in defeat. “Okay,” I said, the word feeling like a stone in my throat. “Okay, Chloe. But you have to be careful with it.”
“Of course! I’ll treat it like it’s my own baby.”
I detached the bowl and the dough hook, placing my dough into a greased bowl to rise on its own. I wiped the machine down and wrote a short, clear list on a sticky note. Do not use metal utensils in the bowl. Clean with a soft cloth only. Do not run motor past speed 6 for more than two minutes. It felt silly and controlling, but necessary.
“Here,” I said, handing her the list. She glanced at it and tucked it into her pocket with a dazzling smile. “You’re the best, Sarah. Seriously.”
She lifted the heavy machine off my counter. It looked wrong in her arms, like a thoroughbred horse being led away by a clown. She bumped it against the door frame on her way out, the solid thwack making me physically flinch. “Oops!” she called back, already halfway to her car.
I stood in my now-quiet kitchen, the empty space on the counter feeling vast and cold. A single yellow sticky note lay on the floor by the door, face down. I didn’t need to pick it up to know what it was.
About the Author
