The flashbulbs popped as my neighbor, Madison, held up the trophy, a triumphant smile on her face and my mother’s rarest flower—the one she’d stolen from my garden under the cover of darkness—in her prize-winning bouquet.
She was the new queen of our perfect suburban neighborhood.
Just a few months ago, she was the charming young woman who moved in next door and gushed over my garden. That garden was my life’s work, a living, breathing memory of my late mother.
Madison saw it, and she decided it would be hers.
First, a rare dahlia appeared in her yard. Then a prized rose bush. She claimed they were lucky finds from a boutique nursery.
I knew she was a liar. But our Homeowners Association, the all-powerful HOA, only saw her perfect lawn and big smile. They adored her. They even put her on the committee that judged the very contest she planned to win with my plants.
She thought she had everyone fooled, that she had gotten away with everything.
Little did she know, her award speech was just the opening act, and I had the main event queued up on a giant projector screen for the whole neighborhood to see.
The Seed of Doubt: A Perfect Lawn, An Imperfect Welcome
The moving truck was offensively large. It blocked the entire street, its diesel engine rumbling a low, chesty growl that vibrated through the floorboards of my office. From my second-story window, I watched a team of movers, all muscle and sweat, carry an endless parade of sleek, minimalist furniture into the house next door. The house that had, for six quiet years, been occupied by the Callahans, an elderly couple who kept to themselves and grew immaculate, if boring, petunias.
“Well, there goes the neighborhood,” my husband, Tom, said, handing me a fresh mug of coffee. He stood behind me, his hands resting on my shoulders, as we watched a ridiculously expensive-looking white sectional navigate the front door. “That sofa costs more than our car.”
“Don’t be dramatic,” I said, but he wasn’t wrong. The house had sold in a day, for a price that made my teeth ache, to a young couple we knew only by the name on the flurry of renovation permits taped to the front window: Madison and Chase Montgomery.
Our neighborhood, Oak Creek Estates, was a strange pocket of upper-middle-class suburbia. We had an HOA with an iron-fisted grip on mailbox colors and lawn height, and an unspoken social hierarchy that revolved around summer barbecues and who had the greenest grass. The crown jewel of this suburban kingdom was the annual “Best Neighborhood Garden” award, a competition taken with the seriousness of a presidential election. My mother had won it three years in a row before she passed, leaving me her house and her garden—a chaotic, beautiful legacy of heirloom plants and rare blooms that was my sanctuary.
A woman emerged from the house, clapping her hands with sharp, directorial authority. She was young, maybe late twenties, dressed in athleisure wear that had never seen a gym. Her blonde hair was pulled into a high, swinging ponytail. That had to be Madison. She pointed a perfectly manicured finger at a mover carrying a large, ornate mirror. “Careful with that! It’s vintage.”
Tom snorted. “I’m going to go mow the lawn. I feel a sudden, desperate need to assert my territory.”
I watched him go, a small smile playing on my lips. But as Madison turned and her gaze swept across our property, her eyes lingered on my garden. It was a riot of late-spring color, the climbing roses my mother had babied for twenty years scaling the trellis, the unique, deep-purple irises standing like sentinels along the fence. Madison’s expression wasn’t one of simple admiration. It was sharper, more focused. It was the look of someone taking inventory.
An Invitation and an Inquisition
A week later, a small, embossed card appeared in our approved HOA-standard mailbox. “You’re invited for coffee and conversation! Let’s be neighbors. Madison.” The script was a loopy, practiced cursive.
“It’s a trap,” Tom said, peering at it over my shoulder as I sliced cucumbers for a salad. “She’s going to try to absorb you into her social-climbing collective.”
“She’s trying to be nice,” I countered, though a knot of unease had already formed in my stomach. “It’s what new neighbors do.”
The next morning, I walked across the fifty feet of pristine sod that separated our properties. Madison’s front porch was already decorated with two enormous ferns in glossy white pots. She opened the door before I could ring the bell, a brilliant, toothy smile plastered on her face. “Sarah! I’m so glad you could make it.”
Her house smelled of fresh paint and expensive candles. The inside was a sterile expanse of white and gray, like a magazine photo you could admire but never live in. We sat at a marble-topped island while a space-age coffee machine hissed and whirred.
“I just have to tell you,” she began, leaning forward with an unnerving intensity, “your garden is absolutely breathtaking. I’ve been staring at it from my kitchen window all week.”
“Thank you. It was my mother’s.”
“Oh, that’s so sweet,” she said, her tone dripping with a sympathy that felt rehearsed. “I’m a complete novice, but I’m dying to start my own. Chase and I, we just feel a beautiful garden really makes a house a home, you know? It’s so important for the neighborhood aesthetic. Especially with the garden competition coming up.”
She spoke about the contest as if it were a given that she’d be entering. Her questions started out general—soil types, sunlight—but quickly became specific. “Those deep red flowers by the birdbath, what are they called? I’ve never seen anything like them.”
“They’re dahlias. A hybrid my mother developed. She called them ‘Crimson Star.’”
“Crimson Star,” Madison repeated, her eyes gleaming. “And the roses on the fence? Are they hard to find?”
“They’re an old heirloom variety. You can’t really buy them.”
The conversation felt less like a friendly chat and more like an interview. I felt like a resource being mined for data. I left an hour later with a vague headache and the distinct feeling that I had just been thoroughly scouted by the opposition.
About the Author
