She let strangers into my house. Smoked in my living room. Left my cat hungry, shaking under the bed like a scared little ghost—and I was supposed to believe it was all just a “harmless visit from a friend.”
I’d trusted Carol with a key to my home, and she turned it into a free-for-all crash pad while I was states away, none the wiser. Whiskers was left to suffer in silence, and I only found out because a quiet neighbor finally spoke up. The smell, the mess, the damage—it wasn’t a mistake. It was a choice. A series of them.
She thought she’d get away with it. That I’d be too polite, too distant, too far away to know. But I had receipts. Real ones. And this time, justice wouldn’t knock—it would kick the damn door down.
The Familiar Façade: A Looming Trip and Lingering Doubts
The email glowed on my screen: “Mandatory Q3 Strategy Summit – Denver.” Mark glanced over my shoulder, sipping his coffee. “Another one? Didn’t you just get back from Chicago?”
I sighed, rubbing my temples. “Tell me about it. This project, ‘Phoenix Rising,’ is apparently going to need all hands on deck, in person. It’s just a week, but still.” My gaze drifted to Whiskers, our sleek black cat, currently sunbathing in a patch of light on the kitchen floor, looking like a furry, liquid puddle of contentment. Leaving him was always the hardest part. Lily, our daughter, was at a sleepover, so the house was unusually quiet, amplifying my travel anxieties.
“Carol again for Whiskers?” Mark asked, already knowing the answer.
Carol. Our next-door neighbor. She’d been watching Whiskers, popping in to feed him and refresh his water, for the past five years whenever we traveled. She always seemed so… neighborly. A bit loud sometimes, her laugh carrying over the fence on summer evenings, but generally harmless. Or so I’d thought. There was that one time, maybe two years ago, I came back and the house smelled faintly, almost imperceptibly, of something sharp, like old smoke, but it was gone so fast I’d convinced myself I imagined it. Carol knew I was practically allergic to cigarette smoke; Mark had to smoke his occasional cigar way out on the back patio. I’d even mentioned it to her specifically – “No smoking in the house, Carol, you know how it affects me.” She’d waved a dismissive hand, “Oh honey, of course not! Wouldn’t dream of it.” I’d let it go. It was probably just the wind carrying something in from outside.
“Yeah, Carol,” I confirmed, pushing that fleeting memory away. “She’s always good with him. And she needs the cash.” That was another thing. Carol always seemed to be just scraping by. Her house, though outwardly similar to ours in this neat suburban tract, had a perpetually unkempt air.
The knot in my stomach tightened. This trip felt different, heavier. Maybe it was just the stress of the Phoenix project, a beast of a thing I was supposed to be wrangling. Or maybe it was that old, dismissed whiff of smoke.
The Usual Arrangement, An Unusual Unease
A few days later, I stood on Carol’s slightly cracked porch, the scent of wilting petunias heavy in the air. “Hey, Carol!” I called, knocking on the screen door.
She appeared, wiping her hands on a faded apron, a wide, slightly strained smile plastered on her face. “Sarah! Hey there! Come on in, honey, if you can find a spot!” Her living room was… cluttered. Stacks of magazines, knick-knacks everywhere, a general sense of things being perpetually out of place. It always made me appreciate my own Marie Kondo-ed sanctuary even more.
“Just wanted to finalize things for Whiskers,” I said, trying to keep my voice breezy. “I leave Tuesday morning, back the following Monday. Same routine as always?”
“You betcha! Little Whiskers will be right as rain with Auntie Carol.” She winked, and it felt a little too broad, a little too practiced. “Food in the pantry, water fresh, a little chin scratch if he’s feeling friendly.”
“Perfect.” I handed her the envelope with the cash – a hundred dollars, same as always. Generous, I thought, for a couple of five-minute visits a day. “And just to remind you, no guests in the house, please. And absolutely, positively no smoking. My allergies have been acting up lately, and it really sets them off.” I tried to make it sound casual, a friendly reminder, but there was an edge to my voice I couldn’t quite control.
Her smile didn’t falter. “Cross my heart, Sarah. You know me. Your house is a temple. Whiskers is a prince.” She patted my arm. “You just go take care of business. Don’t you worry about a thing.”
Walking back to my own clean, orderly house, a wave of unease washed over me. It was probably just pre-trip jitters. Carol was Carol. A bit eccentric, maybe a little messy, but she wouldn’t… she couldn’t… deliberately disrespect my home or neglect Whiskers. Could she? Mark was out back, wrestling with the lawnmower, a comforting, normal sound. I pushed the unease down. I had a major project to focus on.
Departure and a Distant Disquiet
Tuesday morning arrived in a flurry of last-minute packing and Lily’s tearful goodbye hugs – she was back from her sleepover and already missing Whiskers on my behalf. Mark drove me to the airport, his hand squeezing mine. “It’ll be fine. Whiskers will be fine. Carol will be fine.”
“I know, I know,” I said, trying to match his confidence. “It’s just… you know.”
The flight was bumpy. The hotel room in Denver felt sterile. The first two days of the summit were a blur of PowerPoint presentations and lukewarm coffee. I called Mark each night. “How’s Whiskers?” was always my first question, even before asking about Lily.
“Carol texted,” he said the first night. “‘All good with the furball!’ with a cat emoji. See? Fine.”
The second night, another text from Carol relayed through Mark: “Whiskers says hi! Ate all his dinner.” It sounded… plausible. Still, a tiny worm of worry wriggled in my gut. It was the kind of generic update anyone could send, whether they’d actually seen the cat or not. I chided myself for being paranoid. I was a project manager; I dealt in facts and data, not vague suspicions.
I tried to focus on the Phoenix Rising strategy, on flowcharts and deliverables. But images of Whiskers, alone in the quiet house, kept intruding. Was his water bowl really fresh? Did Carol remember he liked his food spread out on the plate, not heaped in a pile? These were the small, specific things I’d always emphasized.
Then, on Wednesday afternoon, during a particularly mind-numbing breakout session on risk mitigation, my personal cell vibrated. An unknown number. Usually, I’d ignore it, but something made me step out into the hallway.
“Hello?”
“Sarah? Sarah Miller?” The voice was female, hesitant. “This is Brenda Jenkins, from across the street? Number 212?”
My heart gave a lurch. Brenda was a quiet woman, kept to herself. Why would she be calling me? “Yes, Brenda? Is everything okay?”
About the Author
