A hollowed-out impression in the dark blue velvet was all that remained of my mother’s gold locket.
My twelve-year-old niece, the family’s designated angel, had finally taken the one thing I couldn’t bear to lose.
Her mother, my sister-in-law, would call me a liar.
She’d paint me as a forgetful, paranoid woman making up vicious stories, the same performance she gave every time one of my sentimental things vanished after they visited.
What that perfect little thief and her vicious mother didn’t count on was that I was done playing their game, and I had just bought the one thing that would turn their quiet, perfect lives into a shrieking, undeniable siren of public humiliation.
The Silence After the Hummingbirds
The house settled into a quiet hum after they left. It was a familiar silence, one that followed every family gathering, but tonight it felt different. Heavier. I ran a dishrag over the already clean granite countertop, the circular motions a poor substitute for the frantic energy buzzing under my skin. My husband, Tom, was in the living room, channel surfing with the volume low, a sign he was decompressing from the social marathon.
The silence wasn’t just the absence of my brother-in-law’s booming laugh or my sister-in-law Cynthia’s high, sharp chatter. It was a pocket of air where something used to be. For the past year, it had become a ritual I dreaded. After they left, I’d do a quiet, secret inventory. A little silver salt spoon from my grandmother. A signed first edition of a poetry book I loved. Small things. Sentimental things. Things you could convince yourself you’d merely misplaced.
Tonight’s party had been for my son Ben’s return from his first semester at college. It was loud and joyful, full of overlapping stories and the clinking of glasses. Cynthia had been in top form, regaling everyone with tales of her daughter Madison’s latest achievements. Madison, at twelve, was the family’s designated angel. Her blonde hair was always in a perfect, glossy ponytail, her manners impeccable. She’d spent most of the evening curled in an armchair, reading a book, a portrait of youthful innocence.
I dried my hands and walked through the dining room, my eyes scanning the mantelpiece. The pair of tiny, porcelain hummingbirds were still there. Good. I continued down the hall toward our bedroom, my heart starting a low, anxious drumbeat against my ribs. It was a stupid feeling, this premonition of loss. It made me feel old and suspicious, two things I never wanted to be. But the feeling was as real as the hardwood floor beneath my feet. On the bureau, next to my jewelry box, was a small, framed photo of my mother. And pinned to the velvet matting beside it, there was usually a small, silver brooch shaped like a swallow in flight. Usually.
A Husband’s Gentle Logic
“Honey?” Tom’s voice came from the living room. “You okay? You’ve been pacing.”
I stood in the doorway of our bedroom, staring at the empty spot on the photo mat. The absence of the swallow felt like a hole punched through the wall. I walked back into the living room and stood in front of the television, blocking his view.
“It’s gone,” I said. My voice was flat.
He muted the TV, his brow furrowing in concern. “What’s gone?”
“The swallow brooch. Mom’s brooch. It was on the bureau.”
Tom sighed, a soft, tired sound. It wasn’t a dismissive sigh, but it was saturated with a gentle, masculine logic that I knew was coming. “Elaine, are you sure? You wore that blue blazer last week, didn’t you check the lapel?”
“I haven’t worn that blazer in a month,” I said, my voice rising slightly. “It was on the mat. I look at it every single day, Tom. It’s gone.”
He got up from the couch and put his hands on my shoulders, his touch meant to be grounding. “Okay, okay. Let’s not jump to conclusions. We had a dozen people in the house. It could have gotten knocked off. It could be under the bureau, or in a drawer…”
“Only one person went into our bedroom,” I said, the words tasting like poison.
His face tightened. “Don’t. Don’t start that again. She’s a kid, Elaine. She’s a sweet kid. What possible reason would she have to take a vintage silver brooch?”
“What reason did she have to take the salt spoon? Or my copy of Ariel? Or the tiny music box that played ‘Für Elise’?” I was ticking them off on my fingers, a litany of small, strange thefts that sounded insane when spoken aloud. “Every time they visit, something of mine, something with meaning, vanishes.”
“Coincidence,” he said, but his voice lacked conviction. He wanted to believe it. For the sake of his brother, for the sake of family harmony, he needed to believe I was just a messy, forgetful, fifty-two-year-old woman. “You’re stressed. Ben’s leaving again in a week. Let’s just look for it in the morning. It’ll turn up. It always does.”
But it never did.
The Angel in Question
I saw her, of course. I always did. It was a magnetic pull, the way my eyes would find Madison in a crowded room. Earlier in the evening, while I was refilling a bowl of chips in the kitchen, I’d seen her slip away from the living room’s noise. Cynthia was holding court, describing in excruciating detail Madison’s selfless volunteer work at the local animal shelter. “She just has a heart of pure gold,” Cynthia had said, beaming. “She feels things so deeply.”
A few minutes later, I walked down the hall to grab a throw blanket from the linen closet. The door to our bedroom, which I’d left slightly ajar, was now almost fully closed. A sliver of light spilled from underneath. I’d paused, my hand on the closet knob, my breath caught in my throat. I heard a faint click, the sound of my jewelry box lid closing.
I should have thrown the door open. I should have marched in there and said, “What are you doing?” But I didn’t. The social contract, the deeply ingrained need to avoid conflict, to not accuse a child, held me paralyzed. What if I was wrong? What if she was just looking for a tissue, or admiring a photograph? The scene that would erupt—Cynthia’s screeching defense, the family schism—was too horrible to contemplate.
So I waited. A minute later, the door opened and Madison emerged, her face a mask of placid innocence. She gave a little start when she saw me. “Oh! Hi, Aunt Elaine. I just needed to use your mirror to check if I had spinach in my teeth.” She smiled, a perfect, toothy grin. There was no spinach.
“Everything okay?” I’d asked, my voice strained.
“Perfect,” she chirped, and then she’d drifted back toward the living room, a ghost in a pink sweater.
Now, standing in the silent house, that moment played over and over in my mind. Her calm, practiced lie. The way her eyes hadn’t flickered. She felt things so deeply, Cynthia had said. I wondered what, exactly, she felt when she palmed a piece of my mother’s memory and slipped it into her pocket.
A Drawer of Ghosts
I couldn’t sleep. Tom’s steady breathing beside me was a rhythm of normalcy that felt utterly alien. I slipped out of bed and padded back to the bureau. In the dark, I opened the top drawer where I kept the most important things. There wasn’t much left. My mother hadn’t been a woman of means, but what she’d had, she’d cherished.
My fingers brushed against the soft velvet pouch that held her wedding band, then the worn leather of my father’s watch. At the very back was the heart of the collection. The heart of my memory of her. I pulled out the heavy, gold locket. It was warm from the residual heat of the day, smooth and familiar in my palm.
I clicked it open. On one side was a tiny, faded photograph of my father, looking impossibly young in his army uniform. On the other, a picture of me, age five, with a gap-toothed smile and scraped knees. My mother had put it in there the day before she died. She’d pressed it into my hand in her hospital bed, her own hand frail and cool. “So you never forget who loves you,” she had whispered, her voice raspy.
I held it tight in my fist, the engraved edges digging into my skin. This was the one. This was the thing I couldn’t bear to lose. The other items were fragments, echoes of a life. The locket was her last word. All the missing pieces—the spoon, the book, the brooch—were just tremors before the earthquake. I knew, with a certainty that chilled me to the bone, that the locket was what Madison, and by extension Cynthia, was really after. It was the prettiest, the most valuable. It was the final prize. And the thought of that perfect, angelic child, with her quiet hands and empty eyes, touching this locket, made a rage I hadn’t felt in years begin to smolder deep in my belly.
An Unwanted Invitation
The phone rang on Tuesday afternoon. It was Cynthia, her voice like chimes in a hurricane. “Elaine! I hope I’m not catching you at a bad time. I was just thinking, it’s been ages since we had a proper, quiet dinner, just the four of us. This Saturday?”
Ages? I saw them four days ago. My hand tightened on the receiver. A quiet dinner was Cynthia’s code for a captive audience. No other family members to act as buffers, no party noise to drown out her monologues. Just me, Tom, her, and her husband, my brother-in-law, Mike, a man so beaten down by his wife’s personality that he communicated mostly in weary nods.
“Oh, I don’t know, Cynthia,” I started, my mind racing for a plausible excuse. “Tom and I have been meaning to—”
“Nonsense! Madison would be so disappointed. She adores you. She was just saying the other day how she wishes she could spend more time with her Aunt Elaine. Seven o’clock. Don’t be late!”
Before I could formulate another protest, she’d hung up. I stood there, phone in hand, feeling like I’d just been conscripted. Tom came in from the garage, wiping grease from his hands with a rag. He saw my face.
“Let me guess,” he said. “Cynthia.”
“Dinner. Saturday. It wasn’t a request.”
He winced. “Look, honey. Maybe it’s for the best. A small group. Less chaos. Nothing can go missing if we’re all sitting around one table, right?”
His optimism felt like a slap. “You think she confines her stealing to cocktail hour? This isn’t about opportunity, Tom. It’s a compulsion. And Cynthia enables it.”
“Enables it? She doesn’t even believe it’s happening!” he argued, his voice laced with frustration. “Just… let’s go. We’ll keep an eye on things. We’ll have a nice, boring dinner, and we’ll come home, and all your jewelry will be exactly where you left it. It’ll be fine.”
He wanted it to be fine. I wanted, more than anything, to believe him. But the dread that had been my constant companion since Sunday night told me it wouldn’t be.
About the Author
