She pointed a perfectly manicured finger at the lipstick stain she put there herself and called me a liar in front of the whole store.
Her name was Eleanor Vance, and she was our department store’s professional nightmare.
Every week, it was the same game. She’d return a designer handbag or a pair of shoes, claiming they were “defective” when they were perfect.
I had to just smile and scan the refund, because my boss said to keep her happy. Her husband was important, and my job kept a roof over my family’s head.
But this time was different. She didn’t just want her money back for the thousand-dollar dress she ruined.
She wanted to enjoy watching me squirm.
She put on a great show humiliating me for a full refund, but the performance I had planned for her own charity gala would cost her so much more.
The Polished Rot: Same Time, Same Station
The chime above the glass doors of Auden’s department store was supposed to sound elegant. At 10:05 AM on a Tuesday, it sounded like a guillotine dropping. I looked up from the sales report I was trying to decipher, my stomach tightening into a familiar knot. Right on schedule.
Eleanor Vance glided across the polished marble floor of the Handbags & Accessories department. She was a vision in cream-colored cashmere, her blonde hair pulled back in a chignon so severe it looked like it hurt. She didn’t walk; she sailed, a luxury yacht in a sea of us common fishing boats.
“Anna, dear,” she said, her voice a low, melodious hum that always set my teeth on edge. She placed a pristine leather satchel on my counter. The bag was from our exclusive line, retailing for nine hundred and fifty dollars. “This simply will not do. The color is all wrong in natural light. It’s far too… jaundiced.”
I picked up the bag. It was the color of rich caramel, exactly as advertised. There wasn’t a scuff, a mark, or a single sign of use on it. Just like the wallet last week, and the silk scarf the week before that. “I see,” I said, my own voice carefully neutral. I was the department manager. My job was to smooth these things over, to absorb the friction.
“I’ll need a full refund to my card, of course,” she continued, already pulling out her platinum Amex. She didn’t look at me, her attention fixed on a display of new arrivals. It was never a conversation. It was a series of royal decrees.
My district manager, a perpetually stressed man named Peterson, had sent out a memo last month. Our Q3 return rates are unsustainable, especially in high-value departments. Managers will be held accountable. The memo might as well have had Eleanor Vance’s photo on it. She was single-handedly cratering my department’s profitability. Her returns last quarter alone had cost us over twelve thousand dollars in written-off inventory. It was my job on the line.
A Thousand Tiny Cuts
I processed the refund. The receipt spooled out of the machine, a long, flimsy testament to my failure. Eleanor signed the slip with a flourish, then tapped a perfectly manicured nail on the glass counter.
“And the new Fendi collection,” she mused, more to herself than to me. “You were supposed to have it in by the first of the month. It’s the tenth.”
“There was a shipping delay from Milan,” I explained, the words tasting like ash. “We’re expecting it any day now.”
She gave a delicate, dismissive sniff. “That’s what your little assistant said last week. One expects a certain level of competence from a store like Auden’s. Or at least, one used to.”
The insult, one of a thousand tiny cuts she administered, was meant to land. And it did. My assistant, Chloe, was a twenty-year-old college student who worked harder than anyone I knew. I saw Chloe’s shoulders slump from across the floor where she was pretending to organize a shelf.
“I’ll personally call you the moment it arrives, Mrs. Vance,” I said, forcing a smile that felt like it was cracking my face.
She just nodded, her gaze already distant, and sailed away toward the escalators, leaving the refunded handbag sitting on my counter like a corpse. Chloe came over, her face pinched. “I’m so sorry, Anna. I told her what you told me to say.”
“You did everything right,” I reassured her, my voice tight. “Some people just run on a different kind of fuel.”
“Yeah,” Chloe muttered, picking up the bag. “Kerosene, I think.”
The Lipstick on the Collar
The day got worse. Peterson called for a “check-in,” which was corporate-speak for a twenty-minute lecture about my department’s numbers. He didn’t say her name, but we both knew who he meant. The Queen of Returns.
Later that afternoon, my husband, Mark, texted. Leo’s history project is due tomorrow and he hasn’t started. Says he needs a tri-fold board. Can you grab one? I pictured my son, Leo, a lanky fifteen-year-old, blissfully scrolling through TikTok while his grades slipped. Another fire to put out.
The pressure felt physical, like a band tightening around my chest. My salary paid for the mortgage, for Leo’s braces, for the illusion of our comfortable suburban life. My job wasn’t just a job; it was the entire scaffold holding us up.
It was almost closing time when the real bomb detonated. Eleanor Vance reappeared, this time holding a garment bag. My heart sank. She didn’t even shop in ready-to-wear; she was just here to return something from another department, knowing I was the manager on duty. She wanted an audience.
“This is completely unacceptable,” she announced, her voice carrying across the now-quiet store. She unzipped the bag and pulled out a stunning, floor-length ballgown. It was a thousand-dollar dress, midnight blue silk that shimmered under the lights. She pointed to a spot on the inner collar. “A lipstick stain. It was sold to me this way. Damaged.”
I leaned in. There, on the delicate silk, was a faint, waxy smear of crimson. I knew, with a certainty that made me feel sick, that the stain was fresh. It smelled faintly of her perfume. She was claiming it was there when she bought it. She was lying.
“I can assure you, Mrs. Vance, all our garments are inspected—”
“Are you calling me a liar?” she snapped, her voice sharp as glass. A few remaining customers turned to look. My face burned hot. “I host the Heart of the City Gala. I buy a new gown every year. The idea that I would be so clumsy…” She laughed, a short, ugly sound. “Process the return. And I’ll take a gift card for my trouble.”
A Name to the Cruelty
This was it. A line in the sand. I could refuse. I could call her out. And I would be fired before she even reached the parking garage. Peterson’s voice echoed in my head. Keep our high-value clients happy, Anna. Whatever it takes.
I looked at her cold, expectant face. Then I thought of my mortgage, of Leo’s future. The fight drained out of me, replaced by a cold, heavy resignation.
“Of course, Mrs. Vance,” I said, the words automated. “My apologies.”
I refunded the full amount. I processed a one-hundred-dollar gift card. I did it all while she stared me down, a triumphant little smile playing on her lips. She had won. She always won.
I drove home in a daze of fury and shame. I walked into the house to find Mark and Leo arguing over video games. The sight of the un-purchased tri-fold board on the kitchen counter sent a fresh wave of failure through me.
Later that night, unable to sleep, I was scrolling mindlessly on my laptop. An article from a local lifestyle blog popped up on my newsfeed. Eleanor Vance: The Philanthropic Heart of Our City.
There she was. Smiling warmly at the camera, holding a novelty check for a children’s hospital. The article praised her tireless charity work, her grace, her generosity. It quoted her. “Giving back isn’t just a duty,” she said. “It’s a way of life. It’s about integrity.”
I stared at the screen, at the sanctimonious lie of it all. The rage that had been simmering all day boiled over. It wasn’t just about the money anymore. It wasn’t just about my job. It was about the colossal, suffocating injustice of it. The public saint and the private monster.
My fingers trembled as I clicked on a link in the article. It led to the official page for her annual charity event, the one she’d mentioned. The Heart of the City Gala. Her face was plastered everywhere, a beacon of fake benevolence.
I leaned close to the screen, my own reflection a ghostly, furious mask in the glass. “Integrity,” I whispered to the empty room. “You have no idea what that word even means.”
About the Author
